Effect of ultrasonic vibration on microshear bond strength of flowable composite to enamel





Objective: The present study aimed to assess the influence of vibration effect on microshear bond strength (µSBS) of flowable composite to enamel. Material and Methods: Sixty non-carious extracted human premolar teeth were collected and randomly divided into six groups (n = 10) after being trimmed to produce a smooth flat surface: Flowable composites [Wave (SDI), Wave HV (SDI) and Grandioflow (Voco)] were used as bonding agents without or with vibration using an ultrasonic scaler (Mini Piezon, EMS, Switzerland). Composite resin, with an internal diameter of 0.7mm and height of 1mm, was cured on the substrate. The specimens’ µSBS was tested by a microtensile tester (Bisco, USA) at a crosshead speed of 0.5 mm/min. The bond strength values were analyzed using one-way ANOVA and post hoc Tukey test (p < 0.05). Results: Vibration did not lead to any significant difference in the µSBS values of Wave, Wave HV, and Grandio Flow µSBS values (P=0.690, P=1.000 and P=0.947, respectively). No significant difference was found between flowable composites in terms of micro shear bond strength to enamel (p > 0.05). Conclusions: The application of ultrasonic vibration might not be advantageous in terms of improving the shear bond strength of flowable composites to enamel.


Bond strength; Enamel; Flowable composite; Ultrasonic; Vibration.



U. Blunck, Effect of one-year waterstorage on the effectiveness of dentin adhesives in Class V composite resin restorations, J Dent Res 81 (2002) A-139.

A. Najafi-Abrandabadi, S. Najafi-Abrandabadi, A. Ghasemi, P.G. Kotick, Microshear bond strength of composite resins to enamel and porcelain substrates utilizing unfilled versus filled resins, Dent Res J 11(6) (2014) 636.

N. Wilson, S. Dunne, I. Gainsford, Current materials and techniques for direct restorations in posterior teeth: Part 2: resin composite systems, Int Dent J 47(4) (1997) 185-193.

G.L. Unterbrink, W.H. Liebenberg, Flowable resin composites as" filled adhesives": literature review and clinical recommendations, Quintessence Int 30(4) (1999).

M. Inoue, W. Finger, M. Mueller, Effect of filler content of restorative resins on retentive strength to acid-conditioned enamel, Am J Dent 7(3) (1994) 161-166.

Y. Li, M.L. Swartz, R.W. Phillips, B.K. Moore, T.A. Roberts, Materials Science Effect of Filler Content and Size on Properties of Composites, J Dent Res 64(12) (1985) 1396-1403.

R.E. Appeldoorn, T.M. Wilwerding, W.W. Barkmeier, Bond strength of composite resin to porcelain with newer generation porcelain repair systems, J Prosthet Dent 70(1) (1993) 6-11.

A.M. Lacy, J. LaLuz, L.G. Watanabe, M. Dellinges, Effect of porcelain surface treatment on the bond to composite, J Prosthet Dent 60(3) (1988) 288-291.

M.F. Nunes, E.J. Swift, J. Perdigao, Effects of adhesive composition on microtensile bond strength to human dentin, Am J Dent 14(6) (2001) 340-343.

R. Frankenberger, M. Lopes, J. Perdigão, W.W. Ambrose, B.T. Rosa, The use of flowable composites as filled adhesives, Dent Mater 18(3) (2002) 227-238.

R.C. do Amaral, R. Stanislawczuk, C. Zander-Grande, M.D. Michel, A. Reis, A.D. Loguercio, Active application improves the bonding performance of self-etch adhesives to dentin, Journal of dentistry 37(1) (2009) 82-90.

A. Mena-Serrano, T. Costa, R.T. Patzlaff, A.D. Loguercio, A. Reis, Effect of sonic application mode on the resin-dentin bond strength and dentin permeability of self-etching systems, J Adhes Dent 16(5) (2014) 435-40.

B. Bagis, S. Turkaslan, P.K. Vallittu, L.V. Lassila, Effect of high frequency ultrasonic agitation on the bond strength of self-etching adhesives, J Adhes Dent 11(5) (2009).

T.C. Fagundesa, T.J.E. Barata, E. Bresciani, D.F.G. Cefaly, C.A.R. Carvalho, M.F.L. Navarro, Influence of ultrasonic setting on tensile bond strength of glass-ionomer cements to dentin, J Adhes Dent 8(6) (2006).

A. Cantoro, C. Goracci, I. Coniglio, E. Magni, A. Polimeni, M. Ferrari, Influence of ultrasound application on inlays luting with self-adhesive resin cements, Clinical oral investigations 15(5) (2011) 617-623.

J.-H. Jang, B.-K. Jeon, S.Y. Mo, M. Park, D. Choi, K.-K. Choi, D.-S. Kim, Effect of various agitation methods on adhesive layer formation of HEMA-free universal dentin adhesive, Dent Mater J (2018).

H.F. Albers, Tooth-colored restoratives: principles and techniques, PMPH-USA2002.

M. D'Attilio, T. Traini, D. Di Iorio, G. Varvara, F. Festa, S. Tecco, Shear bond strength, bond failure, and scanning electron microscopy analysis of a new flowable composite for orthodontic use, Angle Orthod 75(3) (2005) 410-415.

M. Buonocore, W. Wileman, F. Brudevold, A report on a resin composition capable of bonding to human dentin surfaces, J Dent 35(6) (1956) 846-851.

Y. Shimada, N. Tomimatsu, T. Suzuki, M. Uzzaman, M. Burrow, J. Tagami, Shear bond strength of tooth-colored indirect restorations bonded to coronal and cervical enamel, OPERATIVE DENTISTRY-UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON- 30(4) (2005) 468.

K.L. Van Landuyt, J. Snauwaert, J. De Munck, M. Peumans, Y. Yoshida, A. Poitevin, E. Coutinho, K. Suzuki, P. Lambrechts, B. Van Meerbeek, Systematic review of the chemical composition of contemporary dental adhesives, Biomaterials 28(26) (2007) 3757-3785.

J.-F. Roulet, N.H. Wilson, M. Fuzzi, Advances in Operative Dentistry: Challenges of the future, Quintessence Publishing (IL)2001.

S.E. Bishara, R. Ajlouni, M.M. Soliman, C. Oonsombats, J.F. Laffoon, J. Warren, Evaluation of a new nano-filled restorative material for bonding orthodontic brackets, World J Orthod 8(1) (2007).

D.-B. Ryou, H.-S. Park, K.-H. Kim, T.-Y. Kwon, Use of flowable composites for orthodontic bracket bonding, Angle Orthod 78(6) (2008) 1105-1109.

T. Uysal, Z. Sari, A. Demir, Are the flowable composites suitable for orthodontic bracket bonding?, Angle Orthod 74(5) (2004) 697-702.

W. Finger, C. Tani, Effect of application mode on bonding performance of self-etching adhesives, Am J Dent 18(1) (2005) 41-44.

M. Miyazaki, J. Platt, H. Onose, B. Moore, Influence of dentin primer application methods on dentin bond strength, Oper Dent 21 (1996) 167-172.

M. Tavas, D. Watts, A visible light-activated direct bonding material: an in vitro comparative study, Br J Orthod 11(1) (1984) 33-37.

J. Lee, K. Jang, J. Kim, S. Lee, S. Hahn, C. Kim, Effect of ultrasonic vibration on dentin bond strength and resin infiltration, Am J Dent 16(6) (2003) 404-408.

T. Jacobsen, K. Söderholm, Effect of primer solvent, primer agitation, and dentin dryness on shear bond strength to dentin, Am J Dent 11(5) (1998) 225-228.

D. Fanning, Effect of a filled adhesive on bond strength in three dentinal bonding systems, Gen Dent 43 (1995) 256-262.

C. Amory, J. Yvon, Shear bond strength of a light-cured resin composite vs. dentin characteristics, Dent Mater 10(3) (1994) 203-209.

E. Swift, A. Wilder, K. May, S. Waddell, Shear bond strengths of one-bottle dentin adhesives using multiple applications, Operative Dentistry 22 (1997) 194-199.






Clinical or Laboratorial Research Manuscript